Your EV Might Be Causing More Harm Than Previously Thought

Your EV Might Be Causing More Harm Than Previously Thought

Sharing is caring!

Nadal Deepsin, B.Sc. Climate Science

1. The Environmental Impact of Battery Production

1. The Environmental Impact of Battery Production (image credits: wikimedia)
1. The Environmental Impact of Battery Production (image credits: wikimedia)

The story of electric vehicles often starts with their batteries—and it’s not always a pretty picture. According to a 2024 study in Nature Sustainability, mining for lithium, cobalt, and nickel—the essential ingredients in EV batteries—has triggered severe environmental consequences, including deforestation and major water pollution in places like Chile and the Democratic Republic of Congo. The International Energy Agency (IEA) reported in 2023 that lithium mining has exploded by 500% over the last ten years, raising alarms about the long-term sustainability of this industry. Producing a single battery for an average-sized EV (about 60 kWh) can emit up to 9 metric tons of CO2, based on a 2024 European Commission analysis. These emissions often rival, or even exceed, the carbon savings EVs achieve over their operational life, especially if the battery is manufactured in regions dependent on fossil fuels. Local communities near mines have reported increased respiratory illnesses and water shortages. The scale of resource extraction needed to keep up with growing EV demand is straining already vulnerable ecosystems. These facts make it clear that the green promise of EVs is complicated by what happens long before the car ever hits the road.

2. The Lifecycle Emissions of Electric Vehicles

2. The Lifecycle Emissions of Electric Vehicles (image credits: wikimedia)
2. The Lifecycle Emissions of Electric Vehicles (image credits: wikimedia)

It’s easy to think of electric vehicles as “zero emissions,” but the reality is far more nuanced. A comprehensive lifecycle analysis published by the University of California, Davis in early 2025 showed that once manufacturing, usage, and end-of-life disposal are included, EVs can have similar total emissions to gasoline cars—especially in regions where electricity comes primarily from coal. In some coal-dependent areas, the lifecycle emissions of EVs are now estimated to be 20% higher than previously thought, due to the combination of high-carbon grid power and energy-intensive battery manufacturing. The study also pointed out that in countries with cleaner grids, such as Norway or France, EVs do outperform gasoline vehicles over their lifespan. However, in much of the world—including large parts of the United States, India, and China—the true environmental benefit of driving electric is far less certain. This challenges the simple narrative that all EVs are better for the planet, and raises the stakes for decarbonizing electricity grids everywhere.

3. The Problem of Battery Disposal and Recycling

3. The Problem of Battery Disposal and Recycling (image credits: wikimedia)
3. The Problem of Battery Disposal and Recycling (image credits: wikimedia)

The rapid rise of EVs means that more and more batteries are reaching the end of their usable lives, and the world isn’t ready for the waste. According to a 2024 World Economic Forum report, only about 5% of lithium-ion batteries are currently recycled in an effective manner. Most spent batteries end up in landfills or are exported to countries with lax environmental regulations, where they can leach toxic metals such as lead, cobalt, and nickel into soil and water. The European Union is trying to fix this with new battery recycling laws, but these are not yet fully enforced or adopted across all nations. In the United States, there is no unified national program for EV battery recycling, leaving gaps that are often filled by informal or unsafe practices. The hazardous nature of battery components makes them particularly dangerous if mishandled, with risks of fires and contamination. As more batteries retire each year, the pressure to develop efficient, safe recycling systems is intensifying.

4. The Impact of EV Charging Infrastructure on Urban Areas

4. The Impact of EV Charging Infrastructure on Urban Areas (image credits: pixabay)
4. The Impact of EV Charging Infrastructure on Urban Areas (image credits: pixabay)

The push for more EV charging stations is transforming city life, sometimes for worse as well as better. A 2024 Urban Land Institute study found that the proliferation of charging stations in crowded urban centers has taken over valuable parking spaces, leading to increased congestion and disputes over public land use. In Los Angeles, city officials have struggled to keep pace with demand, resulting in gridlock during peak charging periods and complaints from drivers who can’t find anywhere to plug in. The spike in electricity use from clustered charging points has also strained local grids, occasionally causing brownouts in older neighborhoods not designed for such loads. Some businesses have reported a loss of foot traffic due to charging stations occupying prime parking spots. The situation highlights the need for smarter urban planning and investment in grid upgrades to avoid turning the EV revolution into an urban headache.

5. The Social Justice Implications of EV Adoption

5. The Social Justice Implications of EV Adoption (image credits: pixabay)
5. The Social Justice Implications of EV Adoption (image credits: pixabay)

Not everyone benefits equally from the electric vehicle transition, and the gap is growing. A 2025 Brookings Institution report revealed that lower-income neighborhoods are often left out of the EV boom, lacking both public charging stations and access to purchase incentives. In many U.S. cities, the majority of chargers are concentrated in wealthier areas, making it hard for residents of poorer communities to consider switching to electric. The same report also found that federal and state incentives, such as rebates and tax credits, overwhelmingly go to families earning over $100,000 per year. Communities of color and rural populations are particularly underserved, exacerbating transportation inequalities. Without targeted policies and substantial investment in infrastructure for marginalized areas, the EV transition risks deepening social divides rather than bridging them.

6. The Hidden Costs of EV Ownership

6. The Hidden Costs of EV Ownership (image credits: pixabay)
6. The Hidden Costs of EV Ownership (image credits: pixabay)

Many EV owners are discovering that the promise of lower running costs doesn’t always add up. Consumer Reports’ 2024 analysis concluded that, while routine maintenance for EVs can be cheaper than for gas cars, the overall cost of ownership is often higher due to expensive insurance premiums and unpredictable charging expenses. EV insurance is, on average, 20% more expensive, largely because repairs require specialized parts and tech-savvy mechanics. Charging at home is usually affordable, but for those relying on public networks, prices can spike during peak hours or in busy urban areas. Some EV owners have reported monthly charging bills that rival or exceed what they previously spent on gasoline. Battery replacement—a concern for older models—can cost between $6,000 and $15,000, adding to the total expense over the vehicle’s life.

7. The Role of Renewable Energy in EV Sustainability

7. The Role of Renewable Energy in EV Sustainability (image credits: wikimedia)
7. The Role of Renewable Energy in EV Sustainability (image credits: wikimedia)

The ultimate environmental benefit of an electric vehicle depends heavily on how its electricity is generated. According to a 2025 National Renewable Energy Laboratory study, charging EVs with 100% renewable energy like solar or wind can cut lifetime emissions by up to 70%. However, as of early 2025, about 60% of U.S. electricity still comes from non-renewable sources, including coal and natural gas, which dramatically reduces the green advantage of EVs. In regions where renewables have a larger share, such as parts of Germany and Scandinavia, EVs deliver much greater climate benefits. The slow pace of expanding renewable infrastructure—and the intermittent nature of solar and wind power—means that most drivers cannot yet count on truly clean energy for their vehicles. This underscores the urgent need for grid modernization and expanded renewable generation to fulfill the promise of clean transportation.

8. The Economic Impact of EV Subsidies

8. The Economic Impact of EV Subsidies (image credits: wikimedia)
8. The Economic Impact of EV Subsidies (image credits: wikimedia)

Government incentives have played a big role in boosting EV sales, but the benefits haven’t always reached those who need them most. The Congressional Budget Office’s 2024 report revealed that nearly 70% of federal EV tax credits go to households earning above $100,000 a year. This means that subsidies—funded by taxpayers—are disproportionately helping wealthier Americans buy new cars, while lower-income families are often left out. The same report questioned the efficiency of current subsidy structures and called for a rethinking of incentives to better target underserved groups. Some states have begun experimenting with income-capped rebates or programs for used EVs, but widespread adoption remains limited. The debate continues over how to make the EV revolution both fair and effective.

9. The Future of EV Technology and Innovation

9. The Future of EV Technology and Innovation (image credits: unsplash)
9. The Future of EV Technology and Innovation (image credits: unsplash)

Automakers and tech companies are racing to solve the problems that threaten to undermine the EV revolution. In 2025, Tesla announced a new battery design that could halve manufacturing emissions while boosting energy density, potentially making EVs cleaner and more efficient. Rivian and other startups are experimenting with recycled and bio-based materials for batteries, aiming to cut down on toxic waste and environmental harm. Industry-wide, researchers are looking for ways to replace cobalt and nickel with more abundant and less hazardous materials. However, these innovations face steep challenges: high development costs, uncertain supply chains, and the need for infrastructure upgrades. Widespread adoption of these breakthroughs will depend on collaboration among automakers, governments, and tech firms.

10. The Global Shift Towards Sustainable Transportation

10. The Global Shift Towards Sustainable Transportation (image credits: wikimedia)
10. The Global Shift Towards Sustainable Transportation (image credits: wikimedia)

A global transition to sustainable transportation is accelerating, but it’s not just about electric cars. The United Nations Environment Programme’s 2024 report urges cities and countries to invest in public transit, cycling, and pedestrian infrastructure alongside EV adoption. The report highlights that cities with robust multimodal transport networks can cut traffic emissions by more than 40%, compared to those relying mainly on private vehicles. Governments in Europe and Asia are leading the way with policies that prioritize shared mobility and green urban planning. Despite progress, many cities—especially in North America—still face challenges in reducing car dependency. The push for more balanced, sustainable transportation systems is seen as key to meeting global climate targets and improving quality of life in urban areas.

About the author
Nadal Deepsin, B.Sc. Climate Science
Nadal Deepsin is a climate science specialist focused on environmental change and sustainability. He analyzes climate data to develop solutions for mitigation, adaptation, and long-term ecological balance.

Leave a Comment