What The Decline Of Pollinators Means For American Agriculture

What The Decline Of Pollinators Means For American Agriculture

Sharing is caring!

Hannah Frey, M.Sc. Agriculture

The Pollinator Crisis: A Hidden Agricultural Emergency

The Pollinator Crisis: A Hidden Agricultural Emergency (image credits: unsplash)
The Pollinator Crisis: A Hidden Agricultural Emergency (image credits: unsplash)

Most Americans don’t realize that more than one in five species is at risk of extinction among our vital pollinator population. In agriculture, 87 of the leading global food crops rely on pollinators for their production, which corresponds to 35% of the global production volume of crops grown for human consumption. The scope of this crisis is staggering – we’re talking about the invisible workers that make roughly one-third of our food possible. While you’re reading this, countless bees, butterflies, and other pollinators are disappearing at rates that scientists describe as alarming. The economic implications alone should make every farmer, consumer, and policymaker take notice of this unfolding disaster.

The Staggering Economic Impact: Billions at Risk

The Staggering Economic Impact: Billions at Risk (image credits: pixabay)
The Staggering Economic Impact: Billions at Risk (image credits: pixabay)

Pollinators contribute approximately $18-24 billion annually to the U.S. economy, but that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Between $235 and $577 billion (U.S.) worth of annual global food production relies on their contribution. What makes this even more concerning is that while about 17% of the global crop production value depends on pollination services, crop prices are projected to rise by 30%, leading to a global welfare loss of 729 billion USD, or 0.9% of global GDP if we faced a complete pollinator collapse. Think about that for a moment – nearly three-quarters of a trillion dollars in economic damage. The ripple effects would touch every grocery store, restaurant, and family budget across America.

Colony Collapse Disorder: The Beekeeper’s Nightmare

Colony Collapse Disorder: The Beekeeper's Nightmare (image credits: pixabay)
Colony Collapse Disorder: The Beekeeper’s Nightmare (image credits: pixabay)

Researchers at Washington State University projected that honeybee colonies in the U.S. could decline by up to 70% this year. This isn’t just another academic prediction – it’s already happening. According to recent surveys, beekeepers lost approximately 48% of their managed honey bee colonies in the 2023-2024 period. In total, an estimated 1.6 million honeybee colonies were lost nationwide during this period. The financial consequences are immediate and severe. “I don’t want to be a fear-monger, but this level of national loss could mean increased bankruptcies amongst beekeepers,” Hopkins said. “Growers of crops downstream from almonds may need to scramble if the beekeeper they’ve relied on to pollinate their apple trees, for example, isn’t in business anymore.” When beekeepers go out of business, the entire agricultural supply chain feels the impact.

Almonds: The Poster Child for Pollinator Dependence

Almonds: The Poster Child for Pollinator Dependence (image credits: By This file is a work by Ester Inbar (user:ST or he:user:ST).
More of my work can be found in Category:Files by User:ST.

If you use my work outside Wikimedia I would appreciate being notified and referred to site where used here., Attribution, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=3742547)
Almonds: The Poster Child for Pollinator Dependence (image credits: By This file is a work by Ester Inbar (user:ST or he:user:ST).
More of my work can be found in Category:Files by User:ST.

If you use my work outside Wikimedia I would appreciate being notified and referred to site where used here., Attribution, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=3742547)

California’s almond industry serves as the perfect example of how dependent modern agriculture has become on pollinators. This crop is 100 percent dependent on bee pollination; bees must be present for the trees to produce nuts. The numbers are mind-boggling: Most almond varieties rely on bees for pollination, and each spring approximately 2.8 million honeybee colonies are deployed to pollinate roughly 1.3-1.4 million acres of orchards. During almond pollination season, more than 70% of all commercial honey bee colonies in the United States are used to pollinate almond orchards, which provides as much revenue for U.S. beekeepers as honey production. When this single crop requires such a massive portion of America’s bee population, you start to understand just how precarious our agricultural system has become.

The Pesticide Problem: A Chemical Assault on Nature’s Workers

The Pesticide Problem: A Chemical Assault on Nature's Workers (image credits: Gallery Image)
The Pesticide Problem: A Chemical Assault on Nature’s Workers (image credits: Gallery Image)

The very chemicals we use to protect crops are killing the creatures we need to pollinate them. Using 23 y of data, 14,457 surveys across 2.8 million km2 in the western United States, we demonstrate negative impacts of increasing temperatures and drought and identify nitroguanidine neonicotinoids as the pesticides most impacting the formerly common pollinator, the western bumble bee. This creates a devastating paradox – the tools farmers use to increase yields may be destroying the very foundation of crop production. Pesticides are tools used to kill pest plants, insects, fungi, other pests. Even if they don’t kill pollinators directly, these chemicals can impact the plants that pollnators depend on and leave behind harmful residue that can affect their health for generations. The evidence is clear: our chemical-heavy approach to agriculture is backfiring spectacularly.

Climate Change: Disrupting Nature’s Perfect Timing

Climate Change: Disrupting Nature's Perfect Timing (image credits: unsplash)
Climate Change: Disrupting Nature’s Perfect Timing (image credits: unsplash)

Climate change – Flowering plants may occur farther north or at higher elevations as a response to warming temperatures and may become out of sync with their pollinators. This timing mismatch, called phenological disruption, is creating chaos in agricultural systems. By the 2050s, our most optimistic scenario predicts occupancy declines in almost half of ecoregions; more severe scenarios predict declines in all ecoregions ranging from 51 to 97% for western bumble bees. When flowers bloom before bees emerge, or when migrating butterflies arrive after plants have finished flowering, entire pollination cycles collapse. This isn’t a distant threat – it’s happening right now across American farmland.

Habitat Loss: Paving Over Pollinator Paradise

Habitat Loss: Paving Over Pollinator Paradise (image credits: unsplash)
Habitat Loss: Paving Over Pollinator Paradise (image credits: unsplash)

Pollinators need natural spaces full of flowering plants, grasses, and shrubs to find food and shelter. Agriculture, development, and other human activities are changing these wild spaces that they need to survive. We’re essentially destroying the neighborhoods where pollinators live while expecting them to show up for work in our fields. Habitat fragmentation is likely to affect pollinator movement. It increases energy expenditure, as greater search and travel times are required to travel between them, for reduced resource acquisition which can negatively impact bee health. The irony is striking – in our rush to create more farmland, we’re eliminating the very habitats that support the creatures our farms depend on.

Rising Costs: When Pollination Becomes Unaffordable

Rising Costs: When Pollination Becomes Unaffordable (image credits: pixabay)
Rising Costs: When Pollination Becomes Unaffordable (image credits: pixabay)

The economic pressure is already hitting farmers hard. The average fee for the 2024 almond pollination season for the most common colony strength requirement (seven to nine frames) was $196 per colony, though this ranged from $100 to $220 per colony. The loss rates have driven up the cost of commercial pollination: for instance, the cost of renting honey bee hives for almond pollination rose from about $50 in 2003 to $150-$175 per hive in 2009. These aren’t just numbers on a spreadsheet – they represent real financial stress for farmers already operating on thin margins. Our customers tell us that bees are their second largest expense, after water, equaling approximately 20% of their total growing costs each year.

The Nutritional Crisis: More Than Just Quantity

The Nutritional Crisis: More Than Just Quantity (image credits: unsplash)
The Nutritional Crisis: More Than Just Quantity (image credits: unsplash)

The pollinator decline threatens more than just crop yields – it’s putting our nutritional security at risk. The revised model also reports substantial declines in food production and micronutrient availability such as an 8% reduction in global Vitamin A availability. The nutritional contribution of many animal-pollinated crops in terms of proteins, vitamins and minerals may be much more important for the human diet than the total mass of production would suggest. We’re not just talking about having fewer apples or almonds – we’re talking about fundamental deficiencies in the nutrients that keep us healthy. The crops most dependent on pollinators are often the ones that provide essential vitamins and minerals our bodies need.

Wild Pollinators: The Forgotten Heroes

Wild Pollinators: The Forgotten Heroes (image credits: By Muhammad Mahdi Karim, GFDL 1.2, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=6699147)
Wild Pollinators: The Forgotten Heroes (image credits: By Muhammad Mahdi Karim, GFDL 1.2, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=6699147)

While honey bees get most of the attention, wild pollinators are equally important and facing even greater threats. Bee and butterfly populations are in decline in major regions of North America due to ongoing environmental change, and significant gaps in pollinator research limit our ability to protect these species. The annual production value of wild pollinators for seven crops is over USD 1.5 billion. Aside from maintaining habitats that attract pollinators, native bees arrive at no cost to farmers yet still help improve the quality and quantity of their harvest. These native species often pollinate crops more effectively than honey bees, yet we’re losing them at alarming rates while focusing almost exclusively on managed honey bee colonies.

The Cascading Effect: When One System Fails, Others Follow

The Cascading Effect: When One System Fails, Others Follow (image credits: rawpixel)
The Cascading Effect: When One System Fails, Others Follow (image credits: rawpixel)

The interconnected nature of modern agriculture means pollinator loss creates a domino effect throughout the food system. Taking all this in account, studies suggest crop production would decline by around 5% in higher income countries, and 8% at low-to-middle incomes if pollinator insects vanished. But the real impact goes beyond percentages. If the beekeeping industry begins to regress, then crop production will suffer and we will not be able to access a good food supply with the required variety. When pollinator-dependent crops become scarce or expensive, consumers shift to alternatives, creating new pressures on other parts of the food system. This isn’t just an agricultural problem – it’s a complete food security crisis waiting to happen.

International Trade: America’s Agricultural Competitiveness at Risk

International Trade: America's Agricultural Competitiveness at Risk (image credits: unsplash)
International Trade: America’s Agricultural Competitiveness at Risk (image credits: unsplash)

While about 17% of the global crop production value depends on pollination services, these crops make up an even larger share – 28% – of global agricultural trade. This reflects their strong international demand and higher tradability compared to other agricultural commodities. American agriculture’s competitive advantage in global markets depends heavily on pollinator-dependent crops like almonds, apples, and berries. Almonds are, of course, the most valuable export crop in California. 100% of America’s almond supply comes from here, as well as 80% of the entire world’s supply. If we can’t maintain healthy pollinator populations, we risk losing our dominant position in these lucrative international markets to countries that better protect their pollinators.

The decline of pollinators represents one of the most serious threats facing American agriculture today. From the immediate economic impacts hitting farmers’ bottom lines to the long-term risks to our food security and nutritional health, this crisis demands urgent attention. The evidence is overwhelming, the consequences are already unfolding, and the time for action is running out. Every day we delay addressing this crisis makes the eventual solutions more difficult and more expensive. The question isn’t whether we can afford to act – it’s whether we can afford not to.

About the author
Hannah Frey, M.Sc. Agriculture
Hannah Frey is a climate and sustainable agriculture expert dedicated to developing innovative solutions for a greener future. With a strong background in agricultural science, she specializes in climate-resilient farming, soil health, and sustainable resource management.

Leave a Comment